In a tense Merseyside derby, Liverpool edged out Everton with a narrow 1-0 victory, thanks to Diogo Jota's decisive goal. However, the match was marred by controversy surrounding a tackle from Everton captain James Tarkowski, who many, including his own manager David Moyes, felt was fortunate to avoid a red card. The incident occurred in the 11th minute when Tarkowski lunged to clear a loose ball but caught Liverpool midfielder Alexis Mac Allister just below the knee with his studs.

Referee Sam Barrott initially issued a yellow card for the challenge, a decision that sparked debate among players, pundits, and fans alike. Many believed that Tarkowski's tackle should have warranted a more severe punishment, given its recklessness and the potential danger it posed to Mac Allister. After a brief VAR review lasting only 10 seconds, the decision stood, leaving some to question the criteria for VAR intervention in such situations.

Former players and referees expressed their opinions on the tackle, with many labeling it as a clear candidate for a red card. Ex-England goalkeeper Joe Hart described it as a "reckless" challenge that could have resulted in serious injury. Likewise, former Premier League referee Mike Dean stated that Tarkowski's follow-through was "awful" and suggested that he should have been sent to the pitchside monitor for a review.

While the controversy surrounding Tarkowski's challenge dominated discussions, Liverpool's victory brought them closer to the Premier League title. However, the legitimacy of Jota's goal was also questioned, as Everton claimed offside in the buildup. Despite these contentious moments, Liverpool celebrated a vital three points, while Everton left Anfield feeling aggrieved by the officiating decisions. As the season progresses, these incidents highlight the ongoing debates surrounding VAR and the standards of officiating in the Premier League.