Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim faces a challenging decision regarding his goalkeeping situation after Altay Bayindir's disappointing performance in a recent match against Newcastle. Bayindir, who stepped in for Andre Onana, conceded four goals in a heavy defeat, raising concerns about the team's defensive reliability ahead of a crucial Europa League quarter-final against Lyon.

The Turkish goalkeeper's struggles were highlighted by a particularly poor pass that contributed to Newcastle's fourth goal, further complicating Amorim's decision. Following the match, Amorim acknowledged the team's collective errors, indicating that the performance was not solely the responsibility of Bayindir. However, the manager's choice to drop Onana—who has been under scrutiny for his own mistakes this season—has added pressure to an already critical situation.

Former Manchester United players and analysts have weighed in on Onana's position, suggesting that his absence from the squad against Newcastle might have been a necessary move to alleviate pressure. Despite making several costly errors this season, Onana has been a key figure for the team, and Amorim must now decide whether to reinstate him or continue with Bayindir, who has yet to demonstrate he can handle the responsibilities of a starting goalkeeper at this level.

As Manchester United prepares for their pivotal match against Lyon, Amorim remains non-committal about his starting XI, stating that he will choose the best players for the upcoming game. The stakes are high, as the outcome could significantly impact the club's chances of securing a trophy and qualifying for next season's Champions League. With Onana's future uncertain and Bayindir's confidence shaken, the manager's decision could define the remainder of the season for Manchester United.