In a recent analysis, Danny Murphy highlighted that Manchester United's struggles are not primarily due to their tactical system, but rather the players' inability to execute effectively. After observing their performances across four Premier League matches this season, he notes that while there have been improvements under manager Ruben Amorim's 3-4-2-1 formation, fundamental mistakes continue to cost the team dearly.

Murphy points out that United's defensive issues, exemplified by Phil Foden's opener in the recent derby against Manchester City, stem from player selection and positioning rather than the tactical framework itself. He criticizes Bruno Fernandes for not adequately tracking Foden's run, which allowed the City forward to score. This lack of awareness in defensive situations, according to Murphy, reveals a deeper issue with personnel being misused in roles that do not align with their skill sets.

The analysis also touches on how other players, such as Luke Shaw, are being forced into unfamiliar positions, impacting the team's overall performance. Murphy argues that players need to be placed in roles where they are comfortable, as this will minimize errors and improve the team's effectiveness. He emphasizes that while the system may have its flaws, the right personnel in the right positions can lead to better results.

As United continues to face challenges, Murphy suggests that unless there are changes in player roles and greater attention to individual responsibilities, the team is likely to keep encountering the same problems. He believes that Fernandes, in particular, would be more effective in a traditional number 10 role rather than in deeper midfield duties, and that the coaching staff needs to recognize these nuances to help the team progress.