Andre Onana's tenure at Manchester United has come under intense scrutiny as the team navigates a tumultuous season. Following a series of errors that have seen him contribute to eight goals against his side, Onana is at the center of a critical decision for manager Ruben Amorim as the team prepares for a crucial Europa League quarter-final against Lyon.

Since his £47.5 million transfer from Inter Milan, Onana has faced mounting pressure, particularly after former United player Nemanja Matic labeled him as one of the club's "worst-ever goalkeepers." This statement, coupled with Onana's recent mistakes in the draw against Lyon, has escalated the debate surrounding his future at the club. As Amorim approaches the decision of whether to start Onana or his backup, Altay Bayindir, the implications could significantly impact both players' careers and the team's trajectory.

While Onana was given a break from the Premier League match against Newcastle, the upcoming Europa League match presents a different challenge. Unlike domestic considerations, the decision about who starts in goal could shape the future for both keepers. The one not chosen may seek a transfer this summer, adding further complications to United's financial and squad depth issues.

Onana's struggles have not gone unnoticed, and his performances have been under the microscope since his arrival. His leadership qualities are acknowledged, yet the defensive structure of the team appears to have affected his game. Despite being comfortable off the pitch and speaking English with ease, he is aware that he has not met expectations and feels the weight of responsibility for the team's shortcomings.

As the Europa League campaign progresses, Onana's performance will be pivotal. Should United fail to secure a trophy this season, it could lead to significant changes in the squad, including Onana's potential departure. The club, already burdened with financial commitments from his transfer fee, could face a challenging summer in the transfer market.

Amorim's upcoming decision regarding Onana will not only influence the immediate future of the goalkeeper position but could also define the broader direction of Manchester United as they strive to regain their status among Europe’s elite.